There is a way to buy a home in Florence that costs much less than the market price, but almost no one considers it because it comes with an inconvenient catch: you pay today for a property that you won’t actually move into for ten, fifteen, or twenty years. It’s called bare ownership.

Here’s how it works: you purchase ownership of an apartment, but the person living there (usually an elderly person who wants to obtain cash without leaving their home) retains the right to live there or rent it out for as long as they live. That’s why the price drops—and drops significantly. In exchange, the property cannot be used or rented out for years, and the major expenses fall on the buyer.

Put that way, it sounds like a gamble—and in part, it is. But it’s a gamble with written rules, calculable figures, and risks that can be assessed before signing.

Quick Answer

When is bare ownership a good option? It depends on the time horizon and the condition of the property. It may make sense for those who can tie up capital for ten or twenty years, don’t need that capital to generate income in the meantime, and are prepared to cover extraordinary maintenance costs even before they can move into the home. It is, however, ill-suited for those seeking liquidity, those counting on rental income, or those focused on short-term returns.

What Is Bare Ownership (and What It Isn’t)

Let’s start with what we already know. When you buy a home in the usual way, you acquire full ownership: the right to own the property and the right to use it are in the same hands, and no one distinguishes between the two because there is no reason to do so.

The law, however, allows for these rights to be separated, and that is exactly what is happening here.

On the one hand, there is bare ownership: you are listed as the owner of the property in the records, but that ownership is devoid of the right to use it. On the other hand, there isusufruct: the right to live in the house, or to rent it out and collect the rent, without being the owner. It is one of the oldest legal concepts in our legal system, governed byArticle 978 et seq. of the Civil Code.

It’s worth taking a moment to consider who the parties on either side are, because that’s the key to understanding everything else.

  • On the one hand, there is a person—often an elderly individual—who owns a home but lacks cash: by selling the bare ownership, they receive a significant sum and continue to live where they’ve always lived.
  • On the other hand, there is a buyer who does not need that home right now and is willing to wait in exchange for a discount.

This is not a transaction in which one party takes advantage of the other: it is an exchange between two different and complementary needs, and both parties gain something they would not otherwise have.

The usufruct may be for life, in which case it lasts as long as the usufructuary is alive (the most common form among private individuals), or it may be for a fixed term, set for a specific number of years. This is the most important distinction for anyone evaluating the arrangement as an investment: in the first case, the duration is uncertain; in the second, it is known in advance, and a fixed-term usufruct is an investment of a completely different nature.

Consolidation: What Happens at the End

At this point, the natural question is: what happens next? Once the usufruct has expired, is a new deed required? Are there any additional fees to pay?

No. When the usufruct expires, the two rights are reunited, and the bare owner becomes the full owner without having to purchase anything or execute a new notarial deed. This process is called consolidation, and it occurs automatically: no additional purchase price, no second registration tax. All that remains is to update the formal records with the land registry.

This is the clearest advantage of the entire transaction, and it’s worth keeping in mind because it offsets many of the disadvantages we’ll discuss.

It’s also worth clarifying a term that’s often used and can lead to misunderstandings. You may hear people talk about “deferred income,” but it isn’t income at all: whoever purchases bare ownership receives nothing—at any time—for as long as the usufruct lasts. The value does not come in as a periodic stream. It materializes all at once upon consolidation (when you become the full owner of a property paid for at a fraction of its price) or earlier, by reselling, but under conditions we’ll discuss.

What You Cannot Do

To be clear about what you are buying, it’s also worth specifying what you are not buying. For the entire duration of the usufruct , the bare owner may not live in the property, may not rent it out, and may not decide how it is used. If the usufructuary rents it to a third party, the rent goes to him and not to the owner.

The only option remaining is to sell one’s right to another buyer, who assumes the exact same position.

How Much Is It Worth: Tax Value and Market Price

Now that the mechanism is clear, the first practical question arises: how much should this cost? If, for example, a freehold apartment is worth 400,000 euros, how much is its bare ownership worth? 70%? Half?

The answer is that there are two different numbers, calculated in two different ways, that serve two different purposes. Confusing them is the most common mistake made by those new to this process, so it’s worth keeping them separate from the start.

  • The tax value is what matters to the tax authorities. It is used to determine the amount on which taxes are paid, and it cannot depend on what the parties declare; the law calculates it using a fixed formula that is the same for everyone.
  • The market price, on the other hand, is what the parties actually negotiate. It is influenced by the condition of the property, the neighborhood, the seller’s urgency, and—a factor that is by no means secondary—the number of buyers interested in this type of transaction, which, as we will see, is not very high.

The two figures almost never match, and both are necessary: the first to determine how much tax you’ll pay, and the second to determine whether the deal is a good one.

The coefficients in effect in 2026

The legal formula is based on a single variable: the age of the usufructuary. But before looking at the table listing all the applicable coefficients, it’s important to understand why—otherwise, the numbers may seem arbitrary.

The reasoning is simple: the value of a usufruct depends on how long it is expected to last. A usufruct that is expected to last thirty years is worth a lot, because for thirty years someone will be able to live in or rent out that house. One that is expected to last five years is worth very little. And since the usufruct and bare ownership together make up 100 percent of the property, the older the usufructuary is, the less their usufruct is worth and the more the bare ownership is worth.

The percentages are set by the decree of the Ministry of Economy and Finance dated December 24, 2025, published in the Official Gazette No. 302 of December 31, 2025.

Age of the UsufructuaryValue of the usufructValue of the bare ownership
61–63 years55%45%
64–66 years old50%50%
67–69 years old45%55%
70–72 years old40%60%
73–75 years old35%65%
76–78 years old30%70%
79–82 years old25%75%
83–86 years old20%80%

The official table actually starts at zero years and goes up to ninety-nine; the age brackets listed above cover nearly all actual sales.

Two practical observations:

  1. First: each bracket shifts the percentage by five points, and for a property in Florence, the difference between one bracket and the next amounts to tens of thousands of euros. Here, the date of birth listed on documents is an economic factor.
  2. Second: the brackets are not of equal width, so it is not possible to derive an intermediate value by interpolation. You must necessarily remain within the bracket.

Finally, there is a technical detail worth knowing, because anyone who uses online calculators risks getting their calculations wrong. The statutory interest rate for 2026 is 1.6%, but a rate of 2.5% applies when calculating usufruct and bare ownership: as of 2025, the law does not allow for a rate lower than that threshold, due to the changes introduced by Legislative Decree No. 139 of 2024 to Article 46 of the Consolidated Law on Registration Tax and Article 17 of the Consolidated Law on Inheritance and Gifts.

An Example with Numbers

Laura is evaluating an apartment that, if held in full ownership, would be worth 400,000 euros. The usufructuary is 75 years old, so she falls into the 73–75 age bracket: the bare ownership is worth 65%, or 260,000 euros, while the usufruct is worth the remaining 140,000.

The 260,000 euros is the value the tax authorities assign to the right, not the price Laura will pay: that’s still up for negotiation. And the initial figure of 400,000 is itself an estimate, which must be based on an appraisal and not on the local average, because if the starting value is wrong, all the resulting figures will be wrong as well.

What the Florentine market says

As mentioned earlier, the tax value is calculated on paper. The price, on the other hand, is determined by the market, and it’s worth taking a closer look at what that market is like, because Florence behaves differently from the rest of Italy.

According to a survey by Idealista’s research department for the second quarter of 2026, as reported by La Nazione, listings for bare ownership in Florence account for1.4% of the city’sresidential housing supply, compared to 0.6% nationwide—more than double. The average asking price is 4,794 euros per square meter, about 38% less than for full ownership. In Livorno, the share rises to 1.7%, with a price of 2,295 euros per square meter and a 29% discount.

The first statistic offers some encouragement to those who are looking: in Florence, this market is more prevalent than elsewhere, so there is something worth looking into. The second, however, should be treated with caution in three respects.

  • These are asking prices, not actual sale prices. They reflect what sellers are asking for, not what is actually paid at closing. And in the case of bare ownership, the difference between the two can be significant.
  • The survey includes only areas with at least ten listings during the quarter. This is a limited statistical sample—inevitable in a niche market—but it suggests caution when treating that 38% as a rule that applies to every property.
  • This is an average for all of Florence, not a figure specific to the historic center. It shouldn’t be interpreted as such, and anyone considering an apartment in the center cannot use it as a reference. For the center, you’d need the OMI price indices from the Italian Revenue Agency for that specific micro-area, or data from a real estate agency that actually operates in those streets.

For an overview of the market, the analysis of the the real estate market in Florence in 2026 and the article on how to invest in Florence in 2026.

The 10- to 20-Year Horizon: What the ISTAT Tables Show

We have just seen that the value of bare ownership increases with the age of the usufructuary. At this point, the conclusion seems obvious: if the coefficient depends on age, then the coefficient also tells me how long the usufruct will last.

This is the most costly misunderstanding in the entire subject, and it is wrong.

The ministerial coefficients are used to calculate taxes, and that’s all. They are a tax convention, based on an interest rate set by law, not a demographic estimate.

A 65% rate does not mean that the holding period will be a certain number of years; it simply means that, for tax purposes, that interest is considered equal to 65% of the property. These are two completely separate matters, and confusing them leads to structuring an investment based on a figure that was never intended for that purpose.

To assess life expectancy, other tools are needed: ISTAT’s mortality tables, which indicate the average number of years a person of a certain age has left to live.

The most useful statistic in this regard pertains to age 65, because that is the threshold at which these procedures begin to occur frequently. In 2024 , life expectancy at age 65 in Italy was 19.8 years for men and 22.6 years for women. In Tuscany, it is higher: 20.2 years for men and 22.9 years for women.

It’s worth pausing to consider these figures, because they reveal something specific. Anyone who purchases bare ownership of a property today—where the usufructuary is just over sixty years old—is looking, on average, at a time horizon of about twenty years. Not ten: twenty. And in Tuscany, where life expectancy is higher on average than in the rest of the country, that average is slightly extended rather than shortened. For older age groups, the statistical time horizon shrinks, but it remains in the order of years, not months.

And here’s the crucial point—the one you need to understand before signing: the average is not a prediction for an individual case. A 75-year-old person may live much longer than the average for their cohort, and an investment based on statistical expectations may last ten years longer without anything going wrong, simply because statistics describe groups, not individuals.

There is only one practical consequence: buyers must be prepared to weather the long-term scenario—not as a remote possibility to be ruled out, but as a working assumption to be factored in from day one.

Is it worth investing in bare ownership in Florence’s historic center?

So far, we’ve been discussing the situation in general terms. But what about Florence’s historic center? This is also where this strategy seems most attractive, because that’s where full ownership costs the most.

The honest answer is the one given in the opening box: it depends on the time frame and the condition of the property. In the historic center, however, the second factor carries much more weight than elsewhere, and this shifts the relative balance of the pros and cons.

What works, however, really does work. The lower entry price provides access to properties that would otherwise be out of reach if purchased outright: this is the main reason why some people consider this option. There’s no tenant management involved, so no rent delinquencies, no need to find tenants, and no repairs between rental periods. The property is located in a prestigious area that has historically been relatively unaffected by market fluctuations. And the long-term outlook aligns with that of buyers thinking about their children, not about returns over the next three years.

However, the city center has three specific characteristics that must be weighed against this.

  • The first issue is regulatory restrictions. Florence’s historic center is a UNESCO World Heritage Site, and many buildings are subject to restrictions imposed by the Superintendency. Any work on facades, windows, or roofs requires authorization, with timelines and costs that are significantly higher than those for an ordinary building. The complete picture is provided in the guide on how to buy a historic property in Florence. And since both the properties and the buyers vary between Oltrarno, San Niccolò, and the semi-central areas, it’s best to first figure out how to choose the right neighborhood in Florence.
  • The second option is the most expensive, and it represents the real risk of investing in the city center. As we’ll see in the tax section, extraordinary maintenance remains the responsibility of the bare owner, and in Florence’s historic buildings, this is no mere theoretical expense: a roof replacement or structural reinforcement can run into five-zero figures. This is money you have to shell out for a property you’re not using and that generates no income, and in a historic condominium, that resolution can come at any time. The scale of energy-efficiency upgrades on these buildings is detailed in the analysis onenergy efficiency in historic buildings.
  • The third factor looks to the future, and it’s the one people think about the least. European energy efficiency regulations are driving the market toward energy-efficient properties. An apartment that is classified in a low energy efficiency class at the time of consolidation (and in a historically protected building, upgrading it to a high class is difficult and expensive) may be worth less than anticipated at the time of purchase. Requirements and deadlines are outlined in the article on the Green Homes Directive.

Finally, there is a comparison that almost no one makes—and that should actually be made first—because it represents the real alternative to this transaction. Buying outright and renting it out costs more, but it generates rent starting from the first month, and you can resell it whenever you want on a much broader market. In Florence, student demand supports rental yields in certain areas, as shown by the analysis of returns on university rentals.

With bare ownership, you give up all of this in exchange for the initial discount. It’s a legitimate choice, but it should be made with a clear understanding of exactly what you’re giving up—not something you discover later.

Advantages and Risks

Before moving on to the tax aspects, it’s worth taking a moment to summarize what we’ve covered so far.

BenefitsRisks
Purchase price significantly lower than that of full ownershipUncertain duration of the usufruct: it may far exceed the statistical average
No tenant management and no risk of rent delinquencyCapital tied up for years, with no income in the meantime
Access to properties in areas that would otherwise be out of your budgetDifficult to resell: limited market and long turnaround times
No new purchase tax at the time of consolidationExtraordinary maintenance is the responsibility of the bare owner
Time horizon compatible with family wealth planningThe condition of the property at the time of consolidation cannot be predicted today

Taxes and Costs

Now we know what we’re buying and how much it’s worth. All that’s left to figure out is how much it costs to buy it—and here comes the second piece of good news after the price discount.

When buying from a private seller, you payregistration tax: 2% with first-home tax breaks, 9% in other cases, plus a flat-rate mortgage tax of 50 euros and a flat-rate cadastral tax of 50 euros. The key point is that the tax is calculated based solely on the value of the bare ownership interest, not the entire property. In Laura’s example, the tax applies to 260,000 euros and not 400,000: the discount on the price results in a proportional reduction in taxes.

There is also a second mechanism that further lowers the total cost, which many people only learn about at the notary’s office: the “price-value” method. Upon express request in the deed, an individual purchasing a home can have taxes calculated not on the price paid but on the cadastral value—that is, the cadastral income revalued by 5% and multiplied by 110 for a primary residence or by 120 in other cases. The cadastral value is almost always much lower than the market price, so the savings are substantial.

The question readers may ask themselves at this point is whether this applies here as well or if it is limited to regular purchases. The Italian Revenue Agency’s guide is explicit: the price-value rule also applies to deeds that transfer or establish partial real rights and rights of enjoyment—including bare ownership and usufruct—provided that the properties in question are residential and include their appurtenances. However, it must be requested in the deed, before a notary: it does not apply automatically, and cannot be claimed retroactively.

Primary residence and bare ownership

First-home tax benefits also apply to the purchase of bare ownership alone: the Italian Revenue Agency’s guide recognizes these benefits for the transfer or establishment of real rights of enjoyment (bare ownership, usufruct, use, and habitation) on non-luxury homes. The standard requirements still apply, starting with residency in the municipality within eighteen months of the purchase, which must be declared in the deed.

A note for those who already own bare ownership

Owning a property as a bare owner in another residence within the same municipality does not prevent you from purchasing a home using first-home tax benefits, because the bare owner does not have possession of the property. The only condition is that the bare ownership of that property was not itself purchased using the same tax benefits.

Capital Gains

For individuals, capital gains are taxable only if the sale occurs within five years of purchase. The question here is when the five-year period begins, given that a consolidation has taken place in the meantime.

The answer is in the Resolution No. 218/E of May 30, 2008, of the Italian Revenue Agency: consolidation does not in itself generate a capital gain, and the five-year period begins on the date of purchase of the bare ownership interest. Those who reach the consolidation stage are therefore almost always well beyond the five-year mark and can sell without being taxed.

If, on the other hand, the sale occurs within the five-year period, there is no specific rule establishing how to determine the relevant purchase cost: notarial doctrine adds the value of the usufruct at the time of consolidation to the price of the bare ownership, but this is merely a reconstruction, and it is a question best directed to an accountant.

Who Pays What During the Usufruct Period

The principle is intuitive: whoever uses the house pays for what is needed to use it, and whoever owns it pays for what is needed to maintain it.

Specifically, the Civil Code requiresthe usufructuary to bear the cost of routine maintenance and annual expenses such as taxes (Articles 1004 and 1008). The bare owner remains responsible for extraordinary repairs: ensuring the stability of load-bearing walls and vaults, replacing beams, and rebuilding roofs, floors, and staircases (Article 1005). This is the most significant cost of the arrangement, offset only in part by the fact that the usufructuary must pay the owner interest on the amounts spent.

The question everyone asks remains: what if the usufructuary lets the house fall into disrepair? The Code addresses this. Article 1015 establishes that misuse (deteriorating the property or allowing it to fall into disrepair due to lack of maintenance) can lead to the termination of the usufruct, and the judge may, in the meantime, require a security deposit or transfer possession to the owner. This is not automatic—a lawsuit is required—but the bare owner is not without recourse.

One last thing matters more than the articles: many of these rules can be waived in the deed, and the distinction between ordinary and extraordinary provisions is the most frequent source of disputes. What really matters is not what the Code says, but what is written in the deed. Finally, you’ll need to factor in the notary’s fee, title searches, and taxes: regarding the fee, it’s a good idea to request a written estimate from more than one notary.

For sellers: bare ownership with a reserved right of usufruct

So far, we’ve looked at the transaction from the buyer’s perspective. But it only exists because there’s someone on the other side who’s selling, and understanding their position also helps the buyer navigate the negotiation.

An elderly homeowner can transfer the bare ownership of his or her home while retaining the right of usufruct: he or she receives a substantial sum immediately and continues to live where he or she has always lived, with the same rights as before, for the rest of his or her life. He or she does not lose the home; rather, he or she transfers the value that the home will have after he or she is gone.

It is a source of liquidity, and for many people, it is the alternative to a much harder choice: selling their home and having to move. Those who receive that sum typically use it to supplement their retirement income, cover care expenses, or help their children when they need it—rather than waiting until later.

Precisely for this reason, this decision often intersects with the transfer of assets to one’s children, where the available options (donating, selling, or waiting for inheritance) entail very different costs and consequences. In any case, the first step is always to verification of the property’s legal status: a property that does not comply with regulations will block the transaction regardless of the approach chosen.

How to Buy Safely

From everything we’ve discussed, one practical conclusion follows: a bare ownership purchase is one that must be thoroughly vetted beforehand, because there’s no going back afterward. You don’t have access to the property, you don’t inspect it annually, and you don’t have a say in how it’s maintained. Everything you can possibly know must be determined before signing the contract.

  • The usufructuary and the provisions of the deed. Age verified based on documents, type of usufruct, and what the deed stipulates regarding expenses, the right to rent, and maintenance obligations. As we have seen, many provisions of the Code can be waived: it is here that the quality of the transaction is determined, rather than by the price.
  • Urban Planning and Cadastral Compliance. Consistency Between the Actual Condition of the Property, Building Permits, and Floor Plans: A Guide to the the property’s legal status explains what to ask and whom to ask.
  • Property Condition and Appraisal. A technician is needed to estimate the extraordinary maintenance costs for the next ten to fifteen years—a factor that can make or break the deal. Recent meeting minutes are also useful for determining what work the condominium association has already approved or plans to undertake.
  • Mortgage searches. Mortgages, liens, encumbrances, or third-party rights already registered on the property.
  • Payment terms. Timelines, guarantees, and traceability are defined in the preliminary agreement, not at the closing.
  • Assistance from a real estate agency and a notary. For a transaction intended to last twenty years, this costs far less than a mistake in the deed.

If the buyer resides abroad, the steps outlined in the guide for foreign buyers.

Who It’s Suitable For (and Who It’s Not)

  • It is suitable for those who have capital that can remain invested for ten or twenty years; for those who do not need income from that investment; for those who have the financial capacity to cover an unexpected extraordinary expense related to a property they are not using; to those planning a long-term transfer of assets; and to those who accept that the duration is, by definition, unpredictable.
  • It is not suitable for those who may need to recoup their principal within a reasonable timeframe; those seeking an income, even a modest one; those buying the home they will live in; or those focused on an annual percentage return, because here it cannot be calculated in advance and does not exist until the usufruct expires.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is bare ownership in simple terms?

It is ownership of a property without the right to use or rent it out. That right remains with the usufructuary for the duration of the usufruct: you are the owner on paper and in the land registry, but in the meantime, the house is available to whoever lives there.

Who pays taxes and expenses?

Generally speaking, routine maintenance and annual expenses are the responsibility of the usufructuary (Articles 1004 and 1008 of the Civil Code), while extraordinary maintenance is the responsibility of the bare owner (Article 1005), who, however, receives interest from the usufructuary on the amounts spent. Many of these rules can be modified in the deed: the details should be verified in the clauses of the deed before signing, because that is where it is determined who actually pays.

Can bare ownership be resold?

Yes, the right is freely transferable, and the usufructuary’s consent is not required. The point is this: the market is limited, the process can take much longer than with a standard property, and the price is affected by the scarcity of buyers. This is the aspect that needs to be evaluated most carefully if there’s even the slightest possibility that you might need that money sooner than expected.

Can you buy it with a mortgage?

It depends on the financial institution: some banks finance the purchase of bare ownership, while others do not, and the amount, term, and collateral requirements vary significantly. According to the Tecnocasa data cited above, in 2023 about one in four purchases was financed by a mortgage, and that share is growing. You should check with the bank before making an offer to purchase, not after.

What happens at the end of the usufruct period?

Consolidation takes place: the two rights merge, and the bare owner automatically becomes the full owner, without the need for a new deed of sale and without having to pay transfer taxes again. All that remains is to complete the formalities with the land registry.

Can it be used for a primary residence?

Yes: the Italian Revenue Agency’s guide explicitly includes bare ownership among the rights eligible for tax benefits. The standard requirements still apply, starting with taking up residence in the municipality within eighteen months of the purchase. Since this is a property that cannot be lived in for years, this is a point to be clarified with the notary at the time of the deed.

Is it a good idea in Florence’s historic center?

It depends on the time horizon, the condition of the property, and foreseeable extraordinary costs. In the city center, the discounted purchase price is offset by preservation restrictions and above-average maintenance costs, so the calculation should be based on that specific property rather than on the citywide average. The section above goes into more detail.

Do you want to figure out if this transaction makes sense for you?

The difference between a good bare-ownership purchase and capital tied up in the wrong way doesn’t lie in the formula—which is always the same—but in the property itself, the terms of the deed, and the calculations made before signing.

If you’re considering buying an apartment in Florence, or if you’re in the opposite situation and are thinking of selling the bare ownership of your home while continuing to live there, we can go over the numbers together. You can view the properties for sale in Florence that we’re handling, or contact us for real estate consultation with no obligation.